Alcibiades
Hidalgo
Translated by Douglas
French original: "Un
après-midi avec Saddam"
(Le Monde, 2003/03/10)
With
a wave of his right hand, Saddam Hussein interrupted the briefing by
the head of the Cuban Armys intelligence services on the capacities
of the American military forces that were on the verge of punishing
the invasion of Kuwait. Ive had several reports like
this one. My ambassador at the UN sends me them and most of the time
they end up in there, he said, pointing to a marble trash
bin.
The
comment seemed rather for the benefit of the handful of Iraqi military
leaders seated on one side of the long table covered in dates and flowers.
The Cubans opposite them, myself included, who had been sent by Fidel
Castro to attempt to convince his ally in Baghdad of the likely outcome
of a war in the gulf, understood that our afternoon at Al Qadissiyya
palace would be difficult. It was at the very beginning of November
1990. Four months earlier, Iraqs invasion of Kuwait had shocked
the world and worried distant Cuba. One of the islands allies
was defying at once the Arab world, of which Saddam was part, the Iranians,
the Turks, the Israelis and the West in general, in deploying a crushingly
superior military against a little independent neighbor. An incongruous
scenario, that offered unfortunate similarities to the fears that Cubas
own big neighbor caused.
At
first, Cuban diplomacy decided to play the ostrich. After all, the Kuwaitis
were only distant acquaintances. One more absolute monarchy rotting
in a sea of petroleum. Not allied with, of course, but having a penchant
for, the United States. Saddam, however, was an old friend.
At
the heart of the Communist Partys central committee, there were
several of us among the old negotiators drawn from among the Cuban troops
of Angola who proposed, on the contrary, that we distance ourselves
from Baghdads latest adventure. Saddam had already put us in an
awkward position: we had him to thank for a number of misunderstandings
with the non-Islamic clientele of Cuban policy in the third world, as
with his own Arab brothers. Not to mention the numerous opponents of
Iraqs bloody variation on Baathism who had ended up on the end
of a rope in the Square of the Hanged, among whom were almost all of
the local Communists. We needed to separate ourselves from this business
to preserve Cubas fundamental interests.
The
commander in chief decided to criticize the invasion. Cuba, a non permanent
member of the UN Security Council, voted in favor of resolution 660
of August 2 condemning Iraqs actions. Toward the middle of Autumn,
it became obvious that the prolonged occupation of the Emirate, which
Baghdad viewed as its 19th province, and the determination of the United
States, heading an unprecedented international coalition, were leading
to war. A conflict that, according to Cuba, would only offer the chance
for a humongous display of force by the victors of the Cold War. Moscow,
whose star was fading, barely attempted to limit the damage of Iraqs
misstep while avoiding irritating George Bush.
For Havana, where the economy that had hitherto been propped up by the
socialist countries was now beginning its free fall, things couldnt
be worse. Any means would be acceptable to avoid catastrophe, including
a personal appeal to Saddam. This was an idea of El Comandantes:
convince the Iraqi numero uno of the enormity of the military retaliation
that was then being prepared, and of which Cuba was amply informed thanks
to its sources that were still in the USSR.
The
mission had to be discrete. It would be led by José Ramon Fernandez,
vice president of the Ministerial Council. This career officer and old-hand
of the revolution, a key figure in the battles against the Bay of Pigs
invasion in 1961, enjoyed the total confidence of the Commander in Chief.
Despite his Asturian origins, he was dubbed El Gallego (the
Galician), a name the Cubans gave to all the Spanish. Rodrigo Alvarez
Cambras, the surgeon who several years earlier had removed a tumor from
Saddams spine, earning him top appointments in medicine as well
as politics, was naturally part of the delegation. His presence underscored
the friendly, almost intimate nature of the trip.
As
for me, beyond my new responsibilities in relations outside the central
committee, I had the advantage of knowing the country and its leader
well, after a long stay in the Middle East. In 1975, I was the only
Cuban journalist to go with the Iraqi army through the rocky and frozen
cordilleras of Kurdistan to the headquarters of mullah Mustafa Barzani,
a victory that had consolidated Saddams power over Iraqs
ethnic and religious mosaic.
To
deliver the presentation, Raul Castro chose the young colonel Jaime
Salas, who was then at the head of army intelligence. Body guards, assistants,
translators, and the chancellerys vice-minister for Arab affairs
made up the rest of the delegation. Fidels personal message to
Hussein gathered all the reasons for not allowing Washington to seize
the opportunity to exert global hegemony. The heaviest job fell to colonel
Salas: with Gorbachevs consent, the Soviet military, who were
informed of this mission, had compiled highly detailed descriptions
of the forces deployed on the Arabian peninsula and in Turkey. The Soviet
base Torrens, just outside Havana, collected copious amounts of electronic
data emitted by Florida command centers and from all over North America.
The Cuban military analysts, exhausted from the study of all the armed
conflicts in which the United States had ever been involved, had added
their appraisals. Fidel put the finishing touch on the message: four
pages of reflections in a measured and cordial tone, with the help of
the Gallego Fernandez, who was to present it to Saddam. Then the Cuban
expert most knowledgeable on Soviet matters was charged with editing
a Russian version, with the slight modifications intended to make it
acceptable in Gorbachevs eyes.
Fidel
Castro took leave of us late in the evening at his office in the Palace
of the Revolution. He had examined the diagrams, maps and photographs
in the military dossier and reviewed its arguments one by one. He emphasized
the crucial nature of the mission and the personal risks we would encounter
in entering, at his request, an Iraq already besieged by allied forces.
He saw us as soldiers going off to war. Before bestowing an accolade
on each of us, he had a discrete aside with Fernandez, to whom he gave
a sealed envelope, slipping an arm around his shoulders. For
expenses, he said. in case anything should happen.
An agreement whispered among Gallegos.
We
set out for Madrid and then for Amman, flying first class on Iberia
and then Jordan Airlines. Once in Amman, we were told that Saddams
private jet would take us as far as Baghdad. To travel on board such
a conspicuous aircraft, tracked by hundreds of enemy coalition radar
systems, was not he best option. But there was no other. Declining our
hosts offer was unthinkable and flights into Iraq were forbidden by
the sanctions that were already in place.
Saddams
impeccable jet landed softly that night at Saddam international airport
and we were rapidly taken to the residence prepared for the Cuban mission.
The waiting began. The following day, a first attempt by the Iraqis
to obtain Fidels message met with resistance from Gallego Fernandez,
who then displayed talents worthy of his studies at the Fort Silk artillery
school in Oklahoma: the letter would only be submitted and explained
to its addressee. This absurd game of hide-and-seek lasted several days.
In vain, Alvarez Cambras called on his numerous contacts in the Iraqi
political machine to obtain an audience with Saddam. With no more success,
I tried to meet with Tarik Aziz, whom I had known since that distant
time when he headed a press agency. But Saddam alone decided on his
the use of his precious time.
On
the fourth day, our hosts invited us to pass the time by visiting Babylon,
the reconstruction of which was among the regimes priorities.
We traveled southward. While visiting the paths in which Saddam, ever
the Nebuchadnezzar, had had his name engraved in the thousands of replicated
clay bricks in new constructions, we were urgently recalled to Baghdad:
the meeting would take place the following day.
That
evening the delegation reviewed the subjects to be touched on one last
time. Toward midday, our convoy left for an unknown destination. Juan
Aldama, stationed in Baghdad the previous two years, recognized the
route we were taking. We were being led to the presidents favorite
palace: Radwaniyah, also known as Al Qadissiyya. It was one of Aldamas
last meetings with Saddam. After receiving his diploma the school for
foreign affairs in Moscow, he had returned to Baghdad, his first posting,
in the company of a charming Russian wife, the daughter of an important
Soviet functionary. One Spring evening in 1991 he would fire a bullet
into his temple from the Makarov pistol that he always kept on him.
His suicide was never made public and remains unexplained to this day.
Al
Qadissiyya palace is one of the presidential residences suspected of
housing lethal weapons laboratories. Our convoy passed quickly through
the security checkpoints before arriving at one of the modern Islamic
style buildings. We crossed the length of a hallway lined with Samarkand
ceramic tiles and interior patios with with splendid fountains in order
to arrive at the room scheduled for the meeting. Saddam appeared, followed
by a half dozen high ranking army officers in field dress as impeccable
as their chiefs. He greeted El Gallego with a scarcely amiable
gesture and the latter introduced us in turn. Without going through
the usual introductions, Saddam pointed to his retinue with a vague
motion and invited us to be seated around a long table in the middle
of the room.
El
Gallego began to speak. Our conduct was based, he said, on the solid
friendship between Iraq and Cuba, Saddam and Fidel. The damage that
the conflict would cause the Iraqi government worried us, as did the
benefit that the United States would have in displaying their military
power. The Iraqi listened, impassive. Fidels message was then
submitted to its addressee who read it attentively, with no more reaction
than two or three words muttered under his breath and several movements
of the head that were difficult to read.
After
the long presentation by El Gallego, Saddams impatience was palpable.
It was impossible to discern among his entourage the least sign of approval
for the Cuban position. I understood I had to be brief. A diplomatic
outcome remained conceivable. Among the series of emissaries in Baghdad,
the Soviet diplomats were struggling not to abandon an Arab ally, which
would have been a first. The USSR could be counted on for a last minute
effort at the Security Council that China would sign on to. The representatives
of the third world would stop at nothing to arrive at an honorable solution,
on the condition that Iraq agree to retreat from Kuwait. Territorial
claims could be reformulated another time. The support of Javier Perez
de Cuellar, UN Secretary General and close friend of Havana, was a passkey
for negotiation. The presentation on diplomatic options received no
comment.
Colonel
Salas then approached a blackboard where there was a carefully arranged
display of diagrams, maps, photographs and charts. He described the
various stages of American and allied deployment since the Fall and
specified the characteristics of the troops. He pointed out the latest
developments in desert and amphibious combat, the high degree of readiness,
the adversarys estimated strengths. He identified the points where
the different units were concentrated, the foreseeable operations and
likelihood of concerted action. He made a particularly overwhelming
enumeration of the enemys powerful weapons including many that
would be used for the first time. The colonel spoke of a technological
war, of multiple-head Tomahawk missiles that could be launched from
the Red Sea of the Persian Gulf, of Apache antitank attack helicopters,
of B-52 bombers, of the new F117 A Stealth fighters, undetectable to
radar, Awacs command systems that would simultaneously orient hundreds
of aircraft in combat, Patriot missiles, Abrams tanks equipped with
120 millimeter cannons, new GPS systems, unmanned aircraft and other
smart weaponry, in addition to which there were those of US allies,
all of which would assure that this war resembled no other.
The even-handed but invaluable comparison with the Iraqi forces made
Saddam lose his patience. Though he had remained unmoved before the
description of the capacity for resistance of his infantry, that numbered
fewer than a million men, 7,000 tanks and many fewer pieces of artillery,
as soon as the colonel began to describe the manifest air superiority
of the enemy, Saddam ended the presentation.
After
having shown us in a grave manner the place where diplomatic reports
such as the one he had just heard would crash, he began a diatribe over
the colonial injustice that the State of Kuwait had caused. He condemned
the ingratitude of the Arab nation toward the only one of its members
that had fought against Persian expansion in the Gulf. At first the
victim of maneuvers on the petroleum market, he now found himself isolated
in his new crusade against he West. He criticized the ingratitude of
other friends, hostile to Iraqs decision not to give in before
the enemy, the UNs impotence and the disloyalty of the Communist
nations. He spoke of Saladin, a fellow native of Tikrit, he said, and
then spoke of his date with history and of the formidable lesson that
the Iraqi people, determined to be victorious, would give to any aggressor.
You
can tell comrade Fidel Castro, he said getting up, that
I thank him for his solicitude. If the troops of the United States invade
Iraq, we shall crush them like that, he concluded resoundingly,
stamping the carpet several times with his shining military boots...
The audience had ended. Without smiling, Saddam shook the hands of each
of the Cubans as we left the sumptuous hall. He bid the Gallego farewell
with an Oriental embrace and asked that his greetings be sent to El
Comandante.
That
evening I drew up a long report. Two days later, we returned to Cuba
the way we had come. At the residence of the Cuban ambassador to Madrid,
Fernandez opened the envelope that Fidel had given him and gave each
of us a hundred dollar bill and told us to buy souvenirs. On 12 November
1990, the official newspaper Granma reported the return from Iraq of
an official delegation whose departure had never been announced. Fidel
received us the same day. Without asking us to repeat what happened
again, he only asked the Gallego to imitate with his own feet the gesture
with which Saddam had shown how he would crush the Americans. We spoke
of other things and Fernandez returned the envelope, explaining the
expense from Madrid. El Comandante raised an eyebrow as if surprised
but said nothing.
(Translated
from the Spanish by Carmen Val Julian)
Alcibiades
Hidalgo
Former Cuban ambassador to the United Nations, in July 2002 Alcibiades
Hidalgo secretly left Cuba by sea for Florida. Today he lives in the
United States.